Present situation of
spaceborne SAR
Nobuhiko
Kodaira Remote Sensing Technology Center of Japan
Abstract The launch of spaceborne SAR are
scheduled by ESA, Japan and Canada as E-ERS-1, J-ERS-1 and Radarsat in
1992, 1992 and 1994 respectively. SAR is reputed to be all weather type
remote sensing instruct seat like other passive microwave
radiometer.
In spite of this big advantage, present 3 programs are
limited in single parameter SAR such as Cvv, Lhh, or Chh. So that the
information obtained by these microwave instruments are restricted within
a given application for each instrument. We should have correct
understanding of the present SAR situation.
In this paper, heavy
rain effect to X, C, L, P band SAR, inherent nature of the single
parameter SAR data and the future polarimetric SAR will be described.
Introduction SAR systems are considered to be one of the
most unique remote seasing facilities because of the all - weather
capabilities, independence of time of day and the penetration ability into
the objects. Plenty of SAR data are obtained from spaceborne and airborne
system, however, all of the spaceborne SAR data were single parameter and
near future SAR schedule also shows that single parameter SAR is planned
except SIR-C (Shuttle Imaging Radar-C) as shown in Tabel 1.
SIR-C
is the first spaceborne polarimetric SAR planned by NASA. We are expecting
the polarimetric SAR results from SIR-C experiment.
Table 1. Characteristics of Spaceborne SAR.
|
E-ERS-1 |
SIR-C |
J-ERS-1 |
Radarsat |
EOS-SAR |
SPOT-SAR |
Frequency Polarization |
C/W |
L.C./Quad. X/Dual |
L/HH |
C/HH |
L/Quad. C.X/Dual |
X/Dual |
Resolution on the surface (m) |
30 |
60-20: Standard 30-10: High res. |
18(3-looks) |
8*8(1-looks) 28*30(4-looks) 100*100(6-looks) |
20-30: High res. 50-100:Mid. res. 250: Global obs. |
4-20(1-20 looks) |
Frequency Polarization |
C/W |
L.C./Quad. X/Dual |
L/HH |
C/HH |
L/Quad. C.X/Dual |
X/Dual |
Peak data rate(Mbps) |
165 |
46/channel |
60 |
110 |
180 |
--- |
On board tape recorder |
none |
Yes |
yes |
yes |
yes |
--- |
Incidence angele(degree) |
23** |
15-55 |
38.5 |
20-45 |
15-40 |
12-64 |
Swath width (km) |
90 |
15-90 |
75 |
50 100 400 |
30-50:High res. 100-200:Mid. res. 310-480:Glob. obs. |
20-40 (300-850) |
Main purpose of observation |
Sea ice, Ocean |
Research |
Geology Resources |
Sea ice |
Sea ice Vegetation,Sea ice Soil mois.Geology |
Renewal resources Topog. Soil mois. |
Satellite altitude(Km) |
785 |
250 |
568 |
792 |
620 |
750 |
Equatorial cross, time |
A. M. 10:30 |
Non-sunsynchronous |
A.M. 10:30 |
A.M. 6:00 |
P.M. 1:30 |
A.M. 10:30 |
Antenna dimentions (m) |
1*10 |
2.8/0.8/0.4*2.1 |
2.2*12 |
1.8*15 |
2.6*10.9 |
2.2*8.1 |
Transmit. peak power (kw) |
4.8 |
3.3/2.7/3.4 |
1.1 |
5 |
5.8 |
5 |
Individuality |
Wave Mode |
Multi-Frequency/Polarization |
|
Scan SAR Down Dusk Irbit |
Scan SAR Multi-FReq./Polar. |
Scan SAR Focus Mode |
Launch schedule |
1991 |
1991.2/1992.7 |
1992 |
1994 |
1996, 1998 |
1999 |
Recurrence period(days) |
3* |
--- |
44 |
16(3) |
5 |
7 | * Special observation in
high altitude will be held with a time limit of 3 month after the
launch. ** Incident angle will be changed experimentally by tilting the
spacecraft itself. Single parameter SAR systemSingle
parameter SAR produces monochromatic image. In order to draw a maximum
information from the single parameter SAR data, following methods are
occasionally used under the favorable condition.
- Texture analysis sometimes are used for single parameter image. On
the contrary, optical sensor such as MSS and MESSR have been working for
object indentification and ensure a certain extent of the good results
so far using three or more spectrum Channels. According to our
experiment on texture analysis of SAR image by using co-occurrence
Matrices, forest, vegetation, and cultivated area can be classified with
the insufficient accuracy compared to the optical data. (1)
- Multi-temporal data can be extracted form single parameter SAR data
of different season or different crop period. SAR data is adequate for
this purpose because of the all weather capability. We can observe SAR
data at exact time of period without any delay caused by Weather
conditions. It is useful for identifying the forest and crop by
multi-temporal data.
- Direction of illumination is fixed to the descending and ascending
spacecraft orbit. Theoretically it is possible to use these two
direction as long as the satellite power is enough to make SAR
observation at night orbit. SAR image is very sensitive to the incident
angle to the target, so that in the mountainous area the image of
different direction of illumination contains different information and
shows quite dissimilar image.
- Incident angle can be varied in orbit by some SAR system. In case of
resent scheduled satellites of E-ERS-1 and J-ERS-1 are fixed off-nadir
angle system, however, their off-nadir angle are 20.5 degree and 35
degree respectively. It may be possible to produce sterographic image
from these two SAR data. (2)
Particular characteristics of SAR
data and its drawbacks.
- Rain effect on SAR observation.
All - weather capabilities of SAR
is one of the most distinguished and favorite characteristic.
Meteoroligical radar of wavelength of S-band or shorter observes
rainfall intensity as a routine weather observation. In Japan C-band
weather radar is most common. It is natural to be influenced by heavy
rainfall for C-and X-band SAR. According to simple calculation of back
scattering echo intensity from heavy rain up to 4-mm/hr, rain echo at
L-and P-band SAR is very weak and no rain image will appear. We may
safely say that the rainfall rate of 400 mm/hr is not unusual in the
trop9ics. (3) At C-band, torrential rain over 100 mm/hr will mask the
surface image. At x-band the intensity of rain echo is more strong than
C-band and that of 20 to 30 mm/hr or more will be comparable intensity
to that of natural ground echoes.
- Attenuation
Radar wave attenuation caused by meteorological
particles is negligible for cloud, fog and drizzle as to the frequency
in longer than X-band. In case of radar wave is propagating about 10 km
in slant range through the torrential rain of 25 to 400 mm/hr, X-band
will be suffered by 5 to 70 dB of attenuation. C-band about 1 to 12 dB,
and L-band and P-band will be negligible less than 1 dB.
- Speckle noise is an inherent nature of active microwave system and
is one big drawbacks for SAR images. Usually speckle noise is reduced at
the sacrifice of spatial resolution.
- Side looking system measures the slant range to the target rather
than look angle. Image distortion due to side looking system is very
important nature when incident angle is small. They are foreshortening,
shadow and layover.
- The large power consumption, large antenna size and heavy weight are
required for multi-channel SAR system because the transmitter, receiver
and antenna must be equipped separately for each frequencies. In some
antenna design a common antenna reflector is used.
Future
trend of spaceborne SAR (4)From the reasons given in the preceding
section, polarimetric SAR is considered one of the ideal SAR system, which
include multifrequency and multi-polarization. The number of channels are
decided by the combinhation of these parameters. We can get color image
like the optical sensor, however, information contained in polarimetric
SAR the optical sensor , however, information contained in polarimetric
SAR data is different from that of optical image, development of new
algorithm to analyze the data will be required. Before we reach to this
ideal polarimetric SAR system, there will be middle step of multi-channel
SAR, for instance, two frequency of L-and C-band, dual polarization of HH
and VV will have 4 channel information. The variable off-nadir angle
system contains more information about terrains height.
ConclusionAmong many favorite characteristics such as
all-weather capabilities, there are some disadvantages in connection with
SAR observations which is apt to be hidden in brilliant characteristics of
which is missing at optical sensors. The substantial difference between
SAR and optical remote sensing system comes from following three
characteristic features of the SAR:1) Active sensor, 2) Microwave sensor,
3) Side looking system. Table 2 gives the summaries of SAR features.
Table 2. Merit and demerit of SAR system
System |
Merit |
Demerit |
Active sensor |
Independence of sun angle |
Large power consumption heavy weight Speckle noise |
Microwave sensor |
All - weather capability Penetration into target Sensitive to
soil moisture |
Large anatenna size |
Side looking system |
Sensitive to surface roughness and inclination |
Distortion of layover, foreshortening,
shadow | References
- Kimura, H., T. Iijima and N. Kodaira: 1984 "Experiment on texture
analysis of SAR image by using co-occurence matrices."Proc. the 4th
Japanese Conference on Remote Sensing. Remote Sensing Society of Japan.
- Kimura, H.: 1990 "Geometry of Stereo SAR" Introduction of `Remote
Sensing, Asakurashoten, P. 301-304.
- Moriya, T. et al.: 1989 "Rainfall characteristic in tropics and the
observation method" URSI Commission F, No. 339.
- Evans, D. L. et al.: 1988 "Radar Polarimetry: anaalysis tools and
applications" IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 26-6.
p. 774-789.
|